Silent comedy Conventions

Critically Acclaimed: We've Got Mail #10 | Buster Keaton vs. Charlie Chaplin !

 Due to sound not being used in cinema until almost 1930, filmmakers had to improvise- and with that came genre conventions. In silent comedy, they used their body language to deliver visual jokes rather than facial expressions and dialogue for obvious reasons; those being sound was not invented as well as close-ups being quite difficult to do at the time. Because of this, many key figures adapted a characterising prop to distinguish them- such as Charlie Chaplin's hat and moustache or Buster Keaton's dead pan face. This is also why slapstick comedy became popularised within silent comedy, as well as stemming from Vaudeville (in addition to the use of animals as props and an array of stunts and chases). This greatly appealed to the mainstream working class audience since Vaudeville was seen as the working class version of theatre. Because of these conventions, the use of mise-en-scene became essential to the narratives, which tended to be quite basic and linear. 

Many silent comedy key figures utilised these conventions, such as the "keystone Cops" which heavily relied on the portrayal of the police force as satirised and quite trivial. This resulted in a lot of their films containing many chase scenes. However, other than the representation of the police force, they provided little social commentary in contrast to Charlie Chaplin. 

Charlie Chaplin's films were seen as much more emotive, containing more social commentary on the struggles of the average working class man- this was his star persona: The Everyman. Someone like Harold Lloyd usually played around with these and took on various personas, but was infamous for his romantic suitor persona. 

Buster Keaton also played around with these persona's, taking on roles of each one. Yet what stands out is his outsider clown persona which portrays someone outside of society; a more in depth insight into the human psyche than other silent comedy filmmakers provided. He also took framing into consideration more, and many scenes depended on the framing for the joke to be delivered. His consideration for dimension connects with his expressionism jokes, which not everyone was doing at the time. Although in the industry today, expressionism and abstract editing is encouraged as creativity, it wasn't always viewed this way. Although Keaton often relies on expressionistic gags, his editing was invisible. In the 20's, some filmmakers, such as the Lumiere brothers and Bazin, believed editing was "cheating", and so began the Expressionism Vs Realism debate.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Shaun Of The Dead- Narrative Structure and Genre

Image
Essentially, the first half of the film takes place in the genre of a romantic comedy- the only hint of what's to come is the sound references through film form to the zombie horror genre. In the opening scene the equilibrium of the rom-com genre is set up perfectly- a romantic standstill. The scene  explains Shaun's problems to be: he needs to grow up and mature a little bit for Liz, mend his relationship with his step-father and finally find a solution to ensure Davs and Diane as well as Ed are no longer stuck in the middle of his relationship. The scene opens with a long mid-shot of Shaun smoking in a pub as relaxed diegetic music plays and the camera slowly zooms outwards, establishing our protagonist as well as the setting through the British iconography of  the location- an english pub. One of Shaun's problems is explicitly stated from the offset by Liz. Although we go on to have allegiance for Ed  in a way we agree with Liz. She states "it's
Read more

City of God- End Scene Analysis

Image
  The end scene is crucial for exploring and presenting the ideological themes of the film such as escapism ,urban life and the changing nature of it's crime.  Towards the end of the film, Rocket begins to see light at the end of the tunnel in terms of his escape. Through use of mise-en-scene we are put in a professional office environment which reveals major hope for our antagonist as we haven't seen outside the city before,  however the cool toned lighting which looms over the present day is still prevalent. Finally, in relation to Rocket's escape, he gets another camera from a photographer he looks up to. This can be seen as symbolic for his journey, however Rocket is not the one character upgrading his weapon- Both gangs buy guns from the police yet Lil Ze doesn't pay for them. And thus the "beginning of the end" scene commences and the City Of God is transformed into a war zone.  In the closing scene, we are brought back to the opening scene which enforce
Read more

Trainspotting Opening Scene Analysis

Image
Straightaway as soon as the movie opens we are aligned with Renton through use of voiceover and framing. In contrast to the heavy subject matter, the film narratively opens halfway through a scene, dropping the audience in the midst of action and subsequently engaging them. The non-diegetic upbeat Iggy Pop rock music creates an upbeat and exciting atmosphere and the cinematography is fairly bright and colourful yet at this stage still realistic.  The scene opens with Renton and Spud being chased, running towar ds the camera as Renton delivers his infamous "choose life" monologue. It discusses traditional life yet in a cynical way with an ironic view and satirical tone. According to Renton, life is food, work, material possessions, bills and dental insurance, friendship, ageing and death- and Renton "chooses not to choose life".  Essentially the film's ideology s conveyed through Renton, and at this point in the film the audience is told "who ne
Read more